Today's 10 for Tuesday is near and dear to my heart and my husband's as well. While we have not gone to the midnight movie releases, we did make one of the book releases when we were right down the street from a Borders in Braintree. I have knit three of the super thick house scarves (Hufflepuff for my husband, Slytherin for one of my friends who is now a lawyer and Ravenclaw for me). I have a. Hufflepuff house sweater on the needles for my husband to finish before we go see the final movie later this month.
We are in deep. It's funny though, because I resisted the books for a long time. I was working at a transportation consultation firm when the books became big. Everybody at work from big wig consultants to people in the accounting department were raving about these books. I don't do well with the high expectations given for books or movies (or anything) and resisted reading them. You have to read this, just doesn't work for me. I didn't start until sometime after book 4 came out.
Here are my top 10 things about the Harry Potter books.
1. There is nothing wrong with being intelligent. Hermione shows over and over again that being smart is cool. Both boys and girls need to know that. Some of her intelligence is taken away in the movies, but in the book she is the one both Ron and Harry turn to when they need to know something.
2. The books age with the children. I love that the books grew with their target audience. Books 5 and 6 are too dark for the average 11 year old, but Book 1 helps get them there. I love this series if only it encourages children to read, and a number of adults too.
3. This series encouraged publishers that children's and young adult books do not need to be short. My favorite YA author, Tamora Pierce, thanks the HP world in either Squire or Lady Knight for making her publshers realize that she can have a book over 300 pages. Most of her books since have been much longer. It is awesome!
4. The writing and plotting are not stellar. I know that shouldn't be a bonus, but they are just good enough to show people who want to write how to craft a story and make interesting but bad enough that you get to the sweet spot of "Maybe I can do better." A great example of this in my opinion is the epilogue, which feels very tacked on.
5. The corrallary to #4 is that this series, much like Lord of the Rings, has spawned a tremendous amount of fan fic. I don't read fan fic anymore (The Silver Millenium made my fan fic enabled brain turn into Mary Sue pudding), but it is a great way for people to practice. I mean the world building is already done, which allows people to focus on only a couple of aspects for making good stories.
6. They grow up. I love that I can tell the difference between them from book to book. Of course, that meant I hated Book 5 until I went back and reread Books 1 to 4. Without rereading, Harry's angry angst felt like it came out of the blue. With the reread, it spread as a natural consequence of the ending of Book 4. I love that the stories carry like that. So many series are only not standalone by the carrying of plot and it doesn't feel like it affects the personalities of the characters.
7. The side characters are important too. I love that their importance rises and falls based on how well they mesh with the core 3 and that at least in part each house is represented.
8. Dementors. Unlike the portrayal in the movies, they are not the Nazgul. My interest in the Dementors probably stems from our Harry Potter game that we played umpety years ago. Our keeper of the quote book could list them all out, but at least 2 of our best quotes from that game were Dementor based.
9. I love that JK Rowling is willing to kill off characters. You get to love them (or not as your preference dictates), but no one will necessarily be spared. It makes the conflict more real, because it is war. Heroes are not exempt from the horror.
10. I love that this is the last movie. I shouldn't care, but I do. This has been an impressive franchise, and I will be glad when the movies are over. I'd love to see what the actors do going forward. Unlike Brent Spiner, who I felt never got enough opportunities to move past the role of Data in TNG, the series has encompassed enough emotional time that I don't think they will get pigeonholed. For these young people, that is a wonderful thing for their careers, assuming they are going to keep acting.
Recent Comments